Britain’s £21.7 Billion Carbon Capture Bet: Is It Value for Money?
The UK has committed up to £21.7 billion over 25 years to launch carbon capture…
The UK has committed up to £21.7 billion over 25 years to launch carbon capture projects, yet new figures from Statista highlight how little the technology currently contributes to tackling global emissions.
The contrast deserves scrutiny. Governments are backing expensive infrastructure on the promise of substantial future carbon savings, while the industry’s operational capacity remains small compared with the pollution entering the atmosphere.
That does not establish that every carbon capture project is a waste of money. It does mean ministers must demonstrate why this approach represents good value — and measure success through verified emissions reductions rather than investment announcements.
Global capacity amounts to less than 0.2% of annual emissions
A Statista analysis published on 20 October, drawing on the Global Status of CCS report, identifies 132 commercial carbon capture and storage projects operating worldwide, with combined annual capacity of 68 million tonnes of CO₂.
It reports that approximately 400 million tonnes have been sequestered since 1996, against global CO₂ emissions now exceeding 35,000 million tonnes every year.
Using those figures, current annual capacity amounts to less than 0.2% of annual global emissions. The cumulative quantity stored over three decades is equivalent to roughly four days of emissions at that annual rate.
These comparisons illustrate the industry’s limited scale. They do not establish how efficiently each facility operates: capacity is a measure of potential throughput, rather than verified annual storage.
What has Britain committed?
The government’s £21.7 billion commitment supports the first carbon capture developments associated with the HyNet and East Coast clusters.
HyNet covers north-west England and north Wales, while the East Coast programme is centred on Teesside. The approach involves connecting emitters to shared transport and offshore storage infrastructure.
The money is a long-term funding commitment, rather than £21.7 billion already spent. Spread evenly over 25 years, it would average approximately £868 million annually, although actual payments will follow project contracts and delivery.
There has been tangible progress. The East Coast transport and storage network and Net Zero Teesside reached financial close in December 2024, followed by HyNet’s transport and storage network in April 2025. Government guidance identifies 2028 as the expected operational start for the initial East Coast projects.
Separately, ministers have announced £9.4 billion in capital budgets over the Spending Review period. This covers a different funding timeframe and should not simply be added to the £21.7 billion headline as though both figures represent entirely separate expenditure.
MPs have already questioned the financial case
In February 2025, the Public Accounts Committee warned that the programme carried substantial delivery and value-for-money risks.
It reported that the original ambition to capture 20–30 million tonnes annually by 2030 had been judged unachievable. Around three-quarters of support for the early projects was then expected to come through consumer levies, with the remainder funded by the Exchequer.
The committee also identified maximum contingent liabilities of approximately £34 billion. These represent risks the government has agreed to underwrite, rather than an additional spending bill certain to materialise.
MPs criticised the absence of profit-sharing or equity provisions in the first two contracts, questioning how the public would benefit financially if publicly supported projects became highly profitable.
The department’s defence was that projects would receive almost all support only after becoming operational, with performance conditions intended to protect public money. Nevertheless, payment safeguards alone cannot establish whether a project was the best investment available.
Capturing emissions is different from removing them from the air
An important distinction can become lost in the debate.
Capturing fossil CO₂ at an industrial facility prevents some emissions from reaching the atmosphere. It does not generally remove pollution already there.
Direct air capture extracts CO₂ from ambient air. These are different applications, with different costs and climate benefits. Britain’s industrial carbon capture programme should therefore be assessed against the performance of comparable projects.
Likewise, the relevant outcome is the net emissions reduction across the system. Energy used to capture, compress and transport CO₂, alongside emissions associated with fuel supplies, must be included when calculating the climate benefit.
Where could the investment be justified?
The strongest case concerns industries with emissions that are particularly difficult to eliminate.
The National Audit Office identifies cement production as a sector where carbon capture may be the only practical decarbonisation option. Its assessment also recognises that accepting some early-project risk could be justified if delays or alternative approaches would ultimately cost more.
However, that argument depends on learning from initial projects and bringing future costs down. The NAO has highlighted the importance of capturing those lessons to improve value for money.
For activities with viable alternatives, the financial comparison should be tougher. Public support should be assessed against other ways of delivering the same service with lower emissions, including electrification and improvements in energy efficiency.
Who is behind the projects?
Major oil and gas companies play a central commercial role in Britain’s publicly supported carbon capture programme, particularly:
| UK project | Companies behind it |
|---|---|
| HyNet’s Liverpool Bay CO₂ transport and storage network, serving north Wales and north-west England | Eni |
| Northern Endurance Partnership, providing transport and storage for the East Coast Cluster | BP, Equinor and TotalEnergies |
These roles are documented by the government and the project developers. GOV.UK
Are there alternative ways to reduce emissions?
Targeted investment in energy efficiency, well-sited onshore wind and solar, and measures to cut methane leaks could deliver substantially greater near-term emissions reductions per pound than many carbon capture applications. The IPCC identifies these as major sources of low-cost emissions savings, with some efficiency and renewable energy measures delivering lifetime financial savings compared with existing practices. For Britain, practical options include improving insulation in poorly insulated buildings, upgrading inefficient industrial equipment and installing solar panels where they displace purchased electricity. Their value must still be assessed project by project, including grid and balancing costs for renewables, but they offer a strong case for prioritising measures that prevent emissions cheaply before subsidising expensive systems to capture them. Carbon capture funding should consequently focus on emissions that these alternatives cannot readily eliminate.
Value for money remains to be demonstrated
The global figures show an industry whose contribution remains modest.
They cannot, by themselves, prove that Britain’s future projects will fail.
But a £21.7 billion commitment requires more than confidence in eventual technological progress.
A credible assessment should publish the public cost per tonne of net emissions avoided, actual storage against contracted expectations, the effect on consumer bills and comparisons with realistic alternatives.
There may be a defensible case for targeted carbon capture where other options are limited. A broader assumption that the technology deserves extensive support wherever it can be installed is much harder to justify.
For taxpayers and bill payers, value for money will depend on how much pollution is permanently prevented — and whether the same money could have achieved more elsewhere.
Sources
- Statista: Annual storage capacity of carbon capture facilities worldwide
- UK Government: Carbon capture, usage and storage programme
- Public Accounts Committee: Carbon Capture, Usage and Storage
- UK Parliament: Carbon capture funding, September 2025
- National Audit Office: Carbon Capture, Usage and Storage programme