Scottish Ministers putting £10bn investment in hydropower at risk by refusing to swiftly resolve business rates dispute, says Alba Energy
Industry says Government appears to have dropped the political ball after being offered a simple…
Industry says Government appears to have dropped the political ball after being offered a simple solution to 13-year dispute
Scottish Ministers are putting at least £10 billion of investment in new pumped storage hydro projects at risk by failing to swiftly resolve a thirteen-year dispute over business rates that also threatens the survival of hundreds of existing hydro schemes.
Alba Energy says the Scottish Government appears to have failed to act despite being offered a straightforward solution to the dispute, leaving Scotland’s hydro industry facing business rates far higher than comparable renewable energy technologies.
The criticism follows exchanges in the Scottish Parliament about the economic and energy security opportunities presented by pumped storage hydro developments across Scotland.
“absolutely vital to the energy transition”
Answering questions, Energy Minister Stephen Gethins said pumped storage hydro was “absolutely vital to the energy transition”, adding that the Scottish Government would continue to support investment in projects that would be “vital for creating a flexible, sustainable energy system for the whole of Scotland”.
But when asked separately by MSP Kristopher Leask whether penstocks used in hydroelectric schemes were exempt from business rates under Scotland’s Plant and Machinery regulations, Gethins declined to address the issue, saying: “I can’t comment on matters related to live ratings appeals.” He added that non-domestic property valuations were a matter for independent Scottish Assessors.

Alexander Linklater, Executive Director of Alba Energy, said:
“We met the Public Finance Minister last month and handed her a straightforward solution to a problem that threatens the survival of Scotland’s small hydro sector and at least £10 billion of investment in new pumped storage hydro.
“Instead of acting, ministers are hiding behind an ongoing legal process. But this is the Scottish Government’s own legislation, and our senior counsel has confirmed there is nothing preventing ministers from explaining what it was intended to mean.”
Public Finance Minister Hannah Mary Goodlad met representatives of the hydro sector in September where they pointed out that a minor clarification of Scottish legislation could resolve the dispute without further years of litigation.
But Alba Energy, which represents more than 300 small hydro operators, says ministers appear to have failed to take responsibility for the legislation, leaving the industry facing another costly court battle next year.
“After thirteen years, it looks like the political ball has been dropped unless we hear to the contrary in the next few days. The Government could resolve this issue now, without further costly litigation. Instead, it is putting existing hydro businesses and billions of pounds of new investment at risk.
“If ministers refuse to act, we will pursue our appeal next year. But no one should pretend that another year of litigation, with the future of half of Scotland’s hydro schemes potentially at stake, is either necessary or inevitable.”
The dispute centres on how Scotland’s business rates legislation treats penstocks, the high-pressure pipes used in hydroelectric generating machinery.
In June, the Upper Tribunal rejected the Scottish Assessor’s argument that penstocks were rateable simply because they formed part of the land, but ruled that they could still be valued under other provisions covering pipelines and conduits.
Alba Energy argues that a minor clarification to the Scottish Government’s own Plant and Machinery regulations could resolve the dispute and protect both existing hydro schemes and future pumped storage developments.
The organisation says its legal advisers have confirmed that ongoing court proceedings do not prevent ministers from clarifying the original intention of the legislation.
The industry has warned that without a resolution, many existing hydro schemes could become financially unviable when current business rates reliefs expire, while major pumped storage developers face potentially enormous future rates liabilities.