November 20, 2026

Could Net Zero Profiteers be Creating More Harm, Causing the Public to Lose Belief in Climate Change Reality?

In the global race to combat climate change, “net zero” has become a prominent buzzword….

295 (1)
In the global race to combat climate change, “net zero” has become a prominent buzzword. Countries, corporations, and institutions have all pledged to reduce their carbon emissions to net zero by various dates, often framed as ambitious plans to save the planet. Yet, as the urgency of addressing climate change grows, there is rising skepticism toward these initiatives. Experts are warning that the rush to achieve net zero may be doing more harm than good, as opportunistic profiteers exploit the cause, potentially undermining public trust in the very real and pressing issue of climate change.

The Rise of Net Zero Commitments

Net zero refers to the balance between the amount of greenhouse gases emitted into the atmosphere and the amount removed, achieved through emission reductions and carbon offsetting strategies. Governments and businesses have embraced this goal, often with high-profile announcements. For example, in 2021, the United Kingdom pledged to become a net zero country by 2050, while major corporations like Amazon and Microsoft have committed to reaching net zero carbon emissions even earlier.

However, as these promises proliferate, questions have emerged about the legitimacy of some efforts. There is growing concern that many companies are making pledges with no credible plan to back them up. A 2022 study found that of 25 major global corporations, including household names like Volkswagen and Nestlé, none were on track to meet their self-declared net zero targets. This gap between ambitious pledges and actual progress is becoming a serious issue.

The Problems Resulting from Greenwashing

A major criticism of the net zero movement is the prevalence of “greenwashing”—where companies or governments mislead the public into believing they are more environmentally friendly than they actually are. Take, for example, Shell’s 2021 advertising campaign. The oil giant heavily promoted its net zero ambitions while continuing to invest in fossil fuel extraction projects. Shell was later accused of misleading the public and was investigated by the UK’s Advertising Standards Authority for its claims.

Another well-known example is BP’s “Beyond Petroleum” campaign, which touted the company’s green credentials. However, behind the scenes, BP remained one of the world’s largest oil producers. While BP and Shell publicized their intentions to embrace renewable energy, they simultaneously spent billions lobbying against climate regulations, demonstrating the mismatch between marketing and real action.

This disconnect between lofty promises and minimal action fosters cynicism. The public, bombarded with corporate claims of sustainability, may become skeptical that these pledges are simply marketing tools rather than genuine efforts to reduce emissions. As greenwashing becomes more widespread, trust in climate initiatives could erode, with people questioning whether any of these measures are making a real difference.

Offshoring Emissions – a Concerning Trend

Another concerning trend tied to net zero pledges is the offshoring of emissions by wealthy countries. Rather than truly cutting emissions, some corporations and nations are simply moving their carbon-intensive operations abroad, often to countries with weaker environmental regulations.

A striking example is Tata Steel’s potential closure of its Port Talbot plant in Wales, which is set to be replaced by a new coal-fired blast furnace in India.

While this might reduce the UK’s domestic emissions on paper, it effectively shifts the environmental burden to another part of the world, where coal use will continue to drive emissions. This practice, often referred to as carbon leakage, undermines the global effort to reduce greenhouse gases and highlights the need for international cooperation in climate policy. It also raises ethical concerns about outsourcing pollution to poorer countries, exacerbating global inequalities. By offshoring emissions, wealthy nations may meet their net zero targets without achieving real reductions, perpetuating a cycle of environmental degradation elsewhere​.

This action serves no purpose in effectively reducing carbon emissions, because the planet does not recognise the geographical boundaries humans have imposed, while simultaneously causing economic harm to the families and towns that are impacted by the closure.  It is a disappointing trend.

Over-Reliance on Renewables Could Lead to the West being Reliant on Biggest Global Polluters

As Western nations push to transition exclusively to renewable energy sources, there is a growing concern that these countries may become increasingly reliant on power from countries like India and China, which are continuing to expand their coal-fired power capacity.

The challenges in balancing intermittent renewable sources like wind and solar with constant energy demand could leave Western countries vulnerable to energy shortages. Without adequate investments in grid infrastructure, energy storage, or nuclear power, the West may face periods of low energy production, especially during times of low wind or sun availability.  It is possible that this investment could be made, but we are nowhere near there yet. Nonetheless, this week, we saw the UK close it’s last remaining coal fired power station.

In contrast, both India and China are continuing to build new coal-fired power stations to meet their energy needs and growing industrial demands. According to reports, China approved the construction of over 50 gigawatts (GW) of coal-fired power capacity in 2022 alone, the largest amount in recent years. As of 2024 and 2025, China is expected to add even more coal plants, despite its pledges to peak carbon emissions before 2030. Similarly, India, while increasing its investment in renewable energy, is also expanding its coal power sector, with around 24 GW of new coal plants planned between 2024 and 2025.

This expansion is partly driven by the need for stable, affordable energy sources to support economic growth and industrialization in these countries. For the West, this could mean increased dependency on imported energy or goods produced using coal power, as Western economies continue to decarbonize but struggle to meet all energy demands through renewables alone. This reliance poses both environmental and geopolitical risks, as it may undermine the global efforts to reduce carbon emissions by effectively shifting pollution to countries still reliant on coal.

Furthermore, this scenario raises questions about the long-term sustainability and fairness of global energy policies, where cleaner Western economies could indirectly benefit from the continued use of coal in developing nations like India and China, all while appearing ‘clean and green’, meeting their own net zero targets.

Profiteering from the Climate Crisis – ‘Green Pounds’ are Big Business

As the drive to meet net zero goals intensifies, entire industries have emerged, ranging from renewable energy to carbon trading. While many of these industries are essential for transitioning to a greener economy, there are growing concerns that some are more focused on profit than on environmental outcomes.

The carbon trading market is one area where profiteering has become evident. The concept of carbon offsets—where companies purchase credits to “offset” their emissions—has often been criticized for allowing companies to avoid real change. In some cases, carbon credits are tied to projects that fail to deliver the promised environmental benefits. A 2023 investigation found that more than 90% of the carbon credits sold by Verra, the world’s leading certifier of such credits, were worthless. Many of these credits were linked to forest conservation projects that either failed to prevent deforestation or had negligible impacts on carbon sequestration.

At the same time, the financial sector is benefiting from climate solutions, with investors profiting from green funds and carbon trading platforms. A report from 2020 noted that while trillions of dollars were pouring into green finance, much of the money was funneled into investments that did little to address the root causes of climate change. This raises ethical questions about who really benefits from the net zero movement, and whether the interests of financial institutions are aligned with those of the climate.

Social and Environmental Consequences of Profiting from Net Zero Initiatives

Profiteering from net zero initiatives has had tangible social consequences, particularly in the Global South. Some carbon offset projects have resulted in the displacement of indigenous communities from their ancestral lands, in order to make room for carbon-capturing plantations. One well-documented case occurred in Uganda, where residents were forcibly evicted from their land to make way for a tree-planting project. This highlights the darker side of carbon markets, where local communities suffer while corporations claim they are making progress toward net zero.

The Risk of Public Disillusionment

As net zero profiteering and greenwashing continue, there is a growing risk that the public will lose faith in the climate movement altogether. A notable example of this is the backlash against the European Union’s Emissions Trading System (ETS). Initially introduced to curb industrial emissions, the ETS has been criticized for being overly generous to polluters, allowing them to buy cheap carbon permits rather than invest in cleaner technologies. This has led to a surge in public frustration, as the scheme failed to deliver meaningful reductions in emissions during its early years.

Public trust is crucial for the success of climate policies. When people perceive that the net zero movement is primarily a vehicle for corporate profit, they may become more resistant to necessary changes, such as shifts in energy policy and lifestyle adjustments. This mistrust could delay or derail the urgent climate action required to mitigate the worst effects of global warming.

A Path Forward: Accountability and Transparency

To restore faith in the net zero movement, greater accountability and transparency are essential. First, companies and governments must set clear, measurable targets for reducing emissions, rather than relying heavily on offsetting schemes. In 2022, the Science Based Targets initiative (SBTi), which helps companies set emissions reduction goals aligned with the Paris Agreement, called out several companies for failing to meet their pledges. This push for transparency is a critical step toward ensuring that corporate climate commitments translate into real-world action.

Furthermore, there must be a focus on the social justice aspects of the climate crisis. Marginalized communities must not bear the brunt of net zero initiatives, and the benefits of the green transition must be equitably distributed. For example, a shift toward renewable energy could create millions of jobs, but only if workers in traditional industries are supported through reskilling programs.

Lastly, public education is key. A more informed public can better scrutinize net zero claims and hold corporations and governments accountable. Awareness campaigns, along with independent oversight from watchdog organizations, can help demystify complex concepts like carbon markets and empower citizens to demand meaningful change.

Conclusion

The net zero movement is seen by many as a critical component of the fight against climate change, but it is not without its pitfalls. As profiteers capitalize on the climate crisis and greenwashing runs rampant, there is a real risk that public faith in climate initiatives will erode. To prevent this, transparency, accountability, and social justice must be at the forefront of all net zero efforts. Without these safeguards, the very movement designed to avert climate disaster could end up creating more harm by sowing doubt in the reality of climate change itself – and that’s if all the damage to hearts and minds hasn’t been done already.

If society is to overcome the climate crisis, we must ensure that net zero does not continue to become just another buzzword—but a genuine, equitable pathway to a sustainable future.


References:

  1. UK Government’s Net Zero Strategy: https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/net-zero-strategy
  2. Amazon’s Climate Pledge: https://sustainability.aboutamazon.com/about/the-climate-pledge
  3. Greenpeace critique of carbon offsetting schemes: https://www.greenpeace.org/usa/carbon-offsets/
  4. Shell investigated for misleading net zero claims: https://www.theguardian.com/environment/2021/jun/23/shell-investigated-over-greenwashing-claims
  5. Verra’s carbon credits scandal: https://www.theguardian.com/environment/2023/jan/18/revealed-more-than-90-of-rainforest-carbon-offsets-by-biggest-certifier-are-worthless
  6. The Carbon Markets Debate: https://www.carbonbrief.org/explainer-how-corporate-carbon-offsets-could-fund-global-conservation
  7. Tree Planting project in Uganda (this is not the same as the Welsh project) https://www.wrm.org.uy/bulletin-articles/the-agony-of-a-tree-planting-project-on-communities-land-in-uganda
  8. AI was used for research when compiling this article